Commentary: Education & Taxation
As a typical Libertarian, I believe that government has grown way
beyond its proper scope and function. Many of the difficulties we
read about daily, and see on the TV nightly, and e-mail each other
about incessantly, are caused by a misplacement of power, authority,
and trust in government. I believe in a strong government, but only
to the extent that it does what it was designed to do: protect life,
liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Unfortunately, our government
is presently a major player in several industries that were never in
the vision of the wise founders of this great state, and this great
country.
Education is a case in point. Our government needs to get out of the
education business. It is doing a poor job. It only appears to keep
up ... barely ... by continuing to throw big bucks and big programs at
the problem, of course raising our taxes as it goes. Meanwhile,
parents and other volunteers (including well-meaning "partnership"
companies, agencies, and action groups) are way over-invested in
helping this gigantic and monstrous bureaucracy limp along. Here
comes another season of people crying for new programs, new funds
... calls for tax increases to make these happen. Most everybody
thinks and assumes that we must do this. Most everybody thinks we
have no other choice.
Well, not everybody actually, for we Libertarians know that this would
be throwing good money after bad. We have a solution. We have a real
answer ... and, yes, it's radical. It is radical in the true sense of
the word, meaning "going back to the root or cause of the problem;
dealing with a problem on a fundamental basis." The solution: get the
government OUT of education. We must carefully, gradually, and
compassionately transition from a predominantly government-run
education system to a predominantly free-market system of education.
The problem does not reside in the students, the teachers, the
parents, or even the administrators. The basic problem is that we
have put a central (and often distant) authority in charge of a system
that deserves and truly requires local, private control! Individual
parents (and, of course, pairs of parents) ought to be the fundamental
units of decision and power in our community - just as they are when
it comes to nutrition, housing, and clothing. Do we have a
nationalized or state-run clothing industry? or restaurant industry?
or construction industry? Hell no! Then why in the world do we allow
this when it comes to education?
As a former elementary and middle school teacher (with 17 years of
experience), I have asked myself and others this question literally
thousands of times. The most common response is that we must
guarantee a good education to all children. Be honest and ask
yourself if the government-run system of education has accomplished
this. In fact, we owe a great deal to our kids, and first on my list
is the liberty, dignity, and respect on which this country was
founded. We are a nation of capitalists - free traders. We engage in
business with one another voluntarily -- business that is mutually
beneficial to all parties involved. We abhor government that is too
restrictive, that would infringe on our inalienable rights. As a
parent, I have a moral imperative to feed, house, and clothe my
children. Likewise, I have a moral imperative to educate them. I am
tired of standing by and seeing our government representatives limit
our children's choices to education, and then making us pay for an
inappropriately large portion of their mistakes and bad policy
decisions.
If we really want to see test scores improve ... and we really want to
see our children's aptitudes challenged ... and we really don't want
to see anybody's child left behind, then help me speak out against the
status quo of government-run education. Together, we can de-regulate
the education industry, and then the Invisible Hand of Adam Smith will
perform the wonders that it has performed in those sectors of our
society where free markets flourish.
|